Re: magic immunity

["Sean L. McLane" <zodo@laf.cioe.com>]

> From: "Steven E. Ames" <steve@virtual-voodoo.com>
> Subject: Re: magic immunity
>
> Hrm... magic can for the most part affect immaterial creatures. Today's
> argument is "can a magically created, _PHYSICAL_ effect harm an
> immaterial creature"? Plainly it cannot. You cannot affect the
> immaterial with anything that is material. You'd need an immaterial
> fireball to affect an immaterial creature. At extremely high levels if
> immaterial, the creature is so out of phase with our existence that not
> even magic can affect them, they likewise cannot affect our world...
> even with magic. We can't see them, they can't see us, etc...
>
> -Steve
>

Which brings about one of the original questions:

Can an immaterial person be heard by a material person?

Can a material person be heard by an immaterial person?

If not, this makes a good defense against Divine Word.

The argument has been made that Immaterial people can't affect the material
air around them to make sounds. I've been wondering, in that case, what do
Immaterial people breathe?

-Sean