Re: weapon list to peruse

[Joel Gunderson <belgarat@expert.cc.purdue.edu>]

I can see that...however, the damage from a blunt weapon against someone
in full plate should still be high.  This is due to the fact that whoever
is in the armor, no matter how much the armor is damaged, is still going
to be taking a shload of concussive damage.  It's the same reason why ppl
can't use quarterstaffs in SCA...hit someone in the head no matter what
helmet they are wearing, they will get a concussion.

Joel

On Tue, 8 Sep 1998, Wright Frazier wrote:

> 
> A block of wood has mass, but its gonna knock around someon.  This is
> fine for lesser armors, but against things like full plate its not gonna
> be that effective.
> 
> Further only the last few dp(last 6 or so) is you taking actual horrible
> damage.  till then its dodging juking, getting tuckered out, may be getting
> a few minor cuts and bruises.  a maul is a _TOOL_ not a weapon, and
> is not quickly or easily used.  Hince why it does lower damage.
> If you hit a normal person(6dp) with it, they are seriously hurt or dead.
> If you attack a trained combatant(7+dp) they can dodge a couple of shots,
> or only get a glancing blow that doesn't kill'em.  End result its
> a slow and clumsy weapon that people can dodge,b ut when you do get
> the final hit, they die.
> 
> Halberds on the other hand are fairly easy to use weapons, being designed
> for killing and all.  Hince why its damage is higher.  Its faster and
> easier to use.  Same with greatswords, broad swords, long swords, etc..
> 
> Wright
> 
> 
> > Uh, what?  I'm sure we all recall that cool scene in Braveheart when the one
> > soldier used a maul (a block of wood at the end of a long stick) and virtually
> > crushed the scull of another soldier.  While this was Hollywood, I have it on
> > good authority from many SCA fighters (who study medieval fighting quite
> > deeply) that this was not far from reality.  I'd think the Maul would do a d12
> > but you wouldn't be able to multi-attack with it (it _is_ after all, a large block
> > of wood at the end of a long stick, it takes a second or two to re-cock it for
> > another swing).  Just my two cents based on past discussion with others.
> > 
> > Lyle
> > 
> > -----Original Message-----
> > From:	Wright Frazier [SMTP:khelek@ns1.cioe.com]
> > 
> > [most stuff deleted]
> > 
> > > 3) Heavy 2 handed weapons (notably Maul and Military Pick) seem slightly 
> > > underpowered at 1d8 for striking damage.
> > 
> > a maul is a block of wood, its not going to have the striking power of
> > 	a weapon ment for battle. 
> > 
> > 
> 
>